Totally meant to reblog this days ago nbd
but YEAH all of this. Honestly, I like babygirl-ing a character as much as the next fan, but some people might be in for a shock if S2 even gestures towards the direction I’m expecting and they’ve forgotten that yeah, we were very much warned about this side of Ed in advance. It’s not even in the realm of subtle. That Fang scene is a fantastic example and I think it’s additionally significant that Izzy has been violent towards Fang before this, yet Fang still isn’t scared of him. Izzy is the one who pulls Fang’s beard and who is seen smacking Pete upside the head whenever he gets the chance, but when push comes to shove, it’s not Izzy who Fang is worried about seeing him… what, exactly? Slacking off? Being physically and emotionally vulnerable? Indulging in something too ‘soft’ for piracy? Letting Lucius off the hook and undermining the First Mate’s order? It’s not clear what exactly he thinks Ed will take issue with, but the point is that he’s horrified at the thought of Ed discovering them vs. being totally relaxed as Izzy yells, “What the FUCK?” Despite Izzy being the only one of the two who, technically speaking, has laid a hand on him and other members of the crew.
But that’s because Izzy is primarily bluster and whatever violence he does enact is either a) incredibly tame by a pirate’s standards, or b) severely limited by what he sees as universal rules. His duel with Stede falls under the latter category, him pulling Fang’s beard the former. Sure, we as the audience respond viscerally to that harm because we (hopefully) live in a culture where co-workers don’t manhandle each other in such a manner, but for a pirate it’s on the EXTREMELY chill end of what they might deal with AND it never varies. Izzy is predictable, which is why Fang doesn’t panic. The most Izzy will do is give another slap or a pull and otherwise yell a lot. Ed though? Ed is the wild card. Ed calmly orders a man skinned and drowned (by Fang) because that man insulted him. Ed goes from softly instructing Stede to screaming about putting his knife through a man’s eye. Ed has a heart-to-heart with Lucius in the morning and is throwing him overboard that night. Izzy is an asshole, but he’s a safe asshole because you know what to expect from him, the flip-side of which is that when he’s not yelling or pulling beards, he’s doing what he can to keep the crew alive and functioning well. He’s predictable both in regards to his asshole-ness and his loyalty.
Keep reading